Common Product Engagement Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Common Product Engagement Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Your users aren't engaging with your product the way you thought they would. It's like throwing an awesome party and nobody shows up. 

Feeling frustrated and wondering where you went wrong? You're not alone. Many businesses face similar challenges when it comes to product engagement.

But don’t worry! In this blog post, we'll explore 11 of the most prevalent product engagement mistakes and provide actionable strategies to help you avoid them. 

Whether you're a seasoned product manager or a budding entrepreneur, understanding and tackling these pitfalls can significantly enhance the user experience and drive success for your product.

What Is Product Engagement

Product engagement is the level of interaction and involvement that users have with a digital product. It goes beyond mere usage statistics and encompasses how deeply users are invested in and derive value from the product. 

Essentially, product engagement measures the extent to which users are actively using, enjoying, and finding utility in the product. It is measured using product engagement metrics, including user retention, frequency of usage, and depth of interaction. 

High product engagement indicates that users see value in the product, actively use its features, and are more likely to stay loyal.

11 Common Product Engagement Mistakes and How to Fix Them

Do you find yourself scratching your head, trying to figure out why users sign up but never stick around for the long haul? 

Why aren't they as excited about your product as you are? 

Are you tired of playing guessing games with your audience? 

If you answered "yes" to any of these questions, you might be making some product engagement mistakes. Here are 11 common product engagement mistakes and some actionable strategies to fix them: 

Mistake #1: Failing to Spark the ‘Aha’ Moment Early

In the world of digital products, first impressions matter more than anything else. 

One of the most critical moments in a user's journey with your product is the 'Aha' moment. That instant when they fully grasp the value and potential of what you offer. However, many products make the mistake of delaying this moment, leaving users confused or underwhelmed in the initial stages of their interaction.

When users don't experience that 'Aha' moment early on, they're left feeling confused and disconnected from your product. This confusion often leads to disengagement and, ultimately, users abandoning ship in search of a more immediately gratifying solution.

How to Get Users to the ‘Aha’ Moment Fast

In the journey towards that 'Aha' moment, there's no one-size-fits-all approach. Every product, user, and scenario is unique. However, there are specific tactics you can employ to expedite your users' path to enlightenment:

Craft a Seamless Onboarding Experience

Smooth out the onboarding process to eliminate any bumps in the road for new users. Guide them effortlessly towards that pivotal moment of discovery – when they truly grasp the essence and potential of your product.

Simplify the Learning Curve

Don't let your users get lost in a maze of complexity before they reach their 'Eureka!' moment. Simplify the journey by providing accessible self-serve support. This empowers users to learn at their own pace.

Remove Barriers to Entry

Avoid creating unnecessary barriers that obstruct users on their path to enlightenment. Whether it's demanding credit card details or forcing logins too early, such gateways can impede users' progress. Strive to bring about the 'Aha' moment before encountering these roadblocks.

Mistake #2: Ignoring User Feedback

Understanding and paying attention to what your customers say is very important if you want to make a product they'll really love and trust. Customers feel more connected to a company when they see their opinions matter.

When teams ignore user feedback, they might end up making products that aren't great to use.

How to Gather Meaningful User Feedback 

A great product comes from talking openly and honestly with the people who use it. By regularly getting feedback from users, you can learn a lot about what they want and need.

Here’s some ways to collect feedback: 


Sending out surveys is a great way to gather feedback from a large number of users at once. You can ask specific questions to understand their preferences, experiences, and suggestions for improvement.

Feedback Forms

Having feedback forms on your website or within your app allows users to share their thoughts and opinions easily. Make sure the forms are simple and straightforward to encourage more responses.

User Testing Sessions

Organizing user testing sessions gives you the opportunity to observe how users interact with your product in real-time. You can gather direct feedback, observe pain points, and identify areas for improvement by watching users navigate through your product.

Mistake #3: Overcomplicating the User Interface

Some product teams make the mistake of overcomplicating their user interfaces, bombarding users with unnecessary features, cluttered layouts, and confusing navigation.

When the user interface becomes too complex, users can struggle to find what they need. This leads to frustration, decreased engagement, and even users abandoning the product altogether.

How to Simplify the User Interface

By decluttering and streamlining the interface, you can make it easier for users to navigate, find what they need, and accomplish their tasks efficiently.

Here are some strategies to simplify the user interface:

Streamline Navigation

Organize content logically to simplify navigation. Minimize the number of clicks required to access key features. Clear and intuitive navigation paths help users move seamlessly through the interface.

Focus on Essential Features

Identify core functionalities that align with user needs. Prioritize these features in the interface. Trim down excessive features and options that add complexity without significant value.

Embrace Minimalism in Design

Adopt a minimalist design approach. Use clean layouts, ample white space, and clear visual hierarchy. Eliminate unnecessary elements, visual clutter, and distractions.

Mistake #4: Neglecting Smooth User Onboarding

User onboarding sets the tone for the entire user experience. Neglecting this crucial stage can lead to confusion, frustration, and even abandonment of the product by users.

When user onboarding is not well-planned or executed, users may struggle to understand how to use the product effectively, leading to a higher likelihood of churn.

How to Create an Effective Onboarding Process

To address this mistake, it's essential to focus on creating a smooth and intuitive onboarding process that guides users seamlessly through their initial interactions with the product.

Here are some strategies to ensure smooth user onboarding:

Provide Guided Tours

Offer guided tours or walkthroughs that introduce users to key features and functionalities of the product. Use interactive tutorials or tooltips to provide contextual guidance and assistance.

Offer Personalization

Tailor the onboarding experience based on user preferences and behavior. Use user data to customize the onboarding flow and present relevant content that resonates with each user.

Utilize Support Resources

Create tutorials, step-by-step guides, and support resources readily available to users. These resources can help users navigate the onboarding process independently and troubleshoot any issues they encounter along the way.

Mistake #5: Failing to Personalize User Experiences

Modern users expect personalized experiences tailored to their preferences and behaviors. However, some product teams overlook the importance of personalization, delivering generic experiences that fail to resonate with individual users.

When user experiences lack personalization, users may feel undervalued or overlooked, leading to disengagement and decreased loyalty to the product.

How to Personalize the User Experience

To effectively personalize user experiences, product teams can employ various approaches:

User Segmentation

Divide users into distinct segments based on demographics, behaviors, or preferences. By understanding different user groups, product teams can tailor experiences to better meet the needs and interests of each segment.

Personalized Content

Deliver content that is customized to the specific interests and preferences of individual users. This may involve recommending relevant products, articles, or resources based on past behavior, preferences, or demographic information.

Adaptive Interfaces

Create interfaces that adapt dynamically based on user interactions, preferences, or context. Adaptive interfaces can adjust layout, content, and functionality to better suit each user's needs and preferences, providing a more personalized and intuitive experience.

Mistake #6: Underestimating the Power of Incentives

Overlooking the potential impact of incentives is a common misstep in product engagement strategies. Incentives, such as rewards, discounts, or exclusive offers, can significantly influence user behavior and drive desired actions. 

How to Incentivize for a Better Product Experience

Incorporating incentives into your product experience can bring about remarkable results in enhancing user engagement and retention. 

By strategically implementing various incentive mechanisms, you can motivate users to interact more actively with your product and ultimately foster a stronger connection with your brand.

Here are some ways to do it:


Offering tangible rewards, such as discounts, coupons, or loyalty points, provides users with immediate benefits for their engagement. These rewards serve as powerful motivators to encourage continued interaction and loyalty.

Exclusive Content

Providing users with access to exclusive content, such as premium features, early product releases, or personalized recommendations, adds value to their experience. This sense of exclusivity can foster a sense of belonging and incentivize users to remain engaged.

Gamification Elements

Incorporating gamification elements, such as challenges, badges, or leaderboards, transforms the user experience into a fun and interactive journey. By gamifying interactions, you can create a sense of achievement and competition, motivating users to actively participate and strive for progress.

Mistake #7: Not Utilizing Data and Analytics

Failing to harness the power of data and analytics is a significant oversight in maximizing product engagement and success. Data analysis provides invaluable insights into user behavior, preferences, and interaction patterns, offering a roadmap for enhancing the product experience.

By analyzing this data, product teams can gain a deeper understanding of user needs, identify patterns and trends, and make data-driven decisions to enhance the product experience.

How to Leverage Data and Analytics for Product Engagement  

Here are some tips to help you use data and analytics to your advantage: 

Implement Robust Analytics Tools

Utilize advanced analytics tools to track user interactions, engagement metrics, and conversion rates. By collecting comprehensive data, product teams can gain valuable insights into user behavior and performance trends.

Conduct A/B Testing

Experiment with different variations of features, designs, or content through A/B testing. By comparing the performance of different variants, product teams can identify which changes resonate best with users and optimize the product accordingly.

Utilize Predictive Analytics

Leverage predictive analytics algorithms to anticipate user behavior and preferences based on historical data. By predicting user actions, product teams can proactively tailor the user experience to meet individual needs and preferences.

Mistake #8: Neglecting Mobile Users

With the increasing dominance of mobile users in the modern digital landscape, overlooking the needs of mobile users can be a significant oversight. Mobile users often have different behaviors, preferences, and limitations compared to desktop users, and failing to cater to their specific needs can result in missed opportunities for engagement and conversion.

How to Cater to Mobile Users

To effectively cater to mobile users, it's essential to prioritize their unique needs and preferences. 

Here are some ways to do it:

Responsive Design

Implement responsive design principles to ensure that your product adapts seamlessly to different screen sizes and devices. A responsive design allows mobile users to access and interact with your product comfortably, regardless of the device they're using.

Mobile-Friendly Features

Identify and prioritize features that are particularly beneficial for mobile users. This may include simplified navigation menus, touch-friendly interfaces, and optimized loading times to accommodate slower mobile internet connections.

Performance Optimization

Optimize your product's performance for mobile devices by minimizing page load times, reducing server requests, and optimizing images and other media for mobile viewing. Mobile users are often more sensitive to performance issues, so ensuring a smooth and speedy experience is crucial for engagement and retention.

Mistake #9: Overlooking Accessibility

Accessibility issues can significantly limit engagement among users with disabilities, hindering their ability to fully access and interact with digital products. 

When products overlook accessibility considerations, they unintentionally exclude a significant portion of the population, leading to reduced engagement, lower satisfaction levels, and potential legal liabilities. 

Users with disabilities may encounter barriers such as inaccessible content, non-intuitive interfaces, or lack of support for assistive technologies, preventing them from fully benefiting from the product.

How to Enhance Product Accessibility

Enhancing product accessibility is crucial for ensuring inclusivity and providing equal opportunities for all users to engage with digital products. 

Here are some tips for enhancing product accessibility:

Compliance with Accessibility Standards

Adhere to established accessibility standards, such as the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), to ensure your product is designed and developed with accessibility in mind. Compliance with these standards helps make content perceivable, operable, and understandable for users with various disabilities.

Inclusive Design Practices

Embrace inclusive design principles throughout the product development process to create products accessible to as many users as possible. Consider diverse user needs and preferences from the outset, rather than addressing accessibility as an afterthought. Involving users with disabilities in the design and testing phases can provide valuable insights and identify potential barriers early on.

Provide Alternative Means of Access

Offer alternative means of accessing content and functionality to accommodate users with disabilities. This may include providing text alternatives for non-text content, implementing keyboard shortcuts for navigation, and ensuring compatibility with screen readers and other assistive technologies. 

Mistake #10: Providing Inadequate Customer Support 

Insufficient customer support can significantly impact user satisfaction and product engagement. When users encounter issues or have questions about your product and cannot find adequate support, they may become frustrated and disillusioned, leading to decreased engagement and even churn.

How to Improve Customer Support

To enhance customer support effectiveness and better serve your users, consider implementing the following strategies:

Knowledge Base

Create a comprehensive knowledge base containing FAQs, troubleshooting guides, and tutorials to help users resolve common issues independently. A well-organized knowledge base can empower users to find answers to their questions quickly and efficiently, reducing the need for direct support interactions.

Multiple Support Channels

Offer users various channels for seeking support, such as email, live chat, phone support, and community forums. Providing multiple support options allows users to choose the most convenient method for them and ensures that they can easily reach out for assistance whenever needed.

Timely Responses

Prioritize timely responses to user inquiries and support tickets to demonstrate your commitment to customer satisfaction. Aim to acknowledge user queries promptly and provide timely resolutions to their issues. Swift responses can help build trust and confidence in your product and brand, fostering stronger user relationships and engagement.

Mistake #11: Underestimating the Impact of UX Copy

Crafting effective product copy and microcopy is crucial for ensuring a seamless user experience and maximizing user engagement. Every word and phrase within your product interface plays a vital role in guiding users and encouraging them to explore further. 

When product copy is poorly written or misplaced, it can lead to confusion and frustration, ultimately driving users away from your app.

The language used in your product copy and microcopy directly impacts user behavior and decision-making. For instance, a clear and action-oriented call-to-action (CTA) button like "Try now" is more likely to prompt user action compared to a vague option such as "Learn more". 

Thoughtfully crafted messaging not only prompts users to take specific actions but also helps bridge the gap between technical terms and everyday language.

How to Improve UX Copy

Enhancing UX copy is vital for creating a user-friendly experience that resonates with your audience. Here are some tips to improve your UX copy. 

Write Conversational Copy

When crafting your copy, aim for a conversational tone that mimics human interaction. This approach helps users feel more comfortable and engaged with your product. Use language that is clear, concise, and relatable to your target audience. 

Be Consistent Across the Product

Consistency is key to providing a seamless user experience. Ensure that your language, terminology, and tone remain uniform across all parts of your product, including interface elements, error messages, and instructional text. 

Use Tooltips

Tooltips are a valuable tool for providing contextual information and guidance to users. Incorporate tooltips strategically throughout your product interface to offer helpful hints, explanations, and instructions. Tooltips can clarify complex features, highlight important actions, and reduce user confusion. However, be mindful not to overwhelm users with excessive tooltips, and ensure that they enhance, rather than distract from, the user experience.


Engagement is about nurturing a connection that goes beyond the initial sign-up and keeps users coming back for more. Therefore, understanding how users interact with your product isn't a one-time task. But it's an ongoing dialogue that requires active listening and adaptation. 

Think of your product as a relationship. Just like any relationship, it needs attention, understanding, and occasional adjustments to thrive. By staying attuned to user needs and feedback, you can continually refine the user experience, making it more meaningful and rewarding.

And when you don't keep up with how customers use your product, it can hurt your business. Customers stick around when they find value and when using your product is a great experience.

So, while improving your product is important, never forget the human element. It's important to work on making the product better, it's just as important to make sure users stay interested, engaged, and satisfied in the long run.


Team Storyly

Group of experts from Storyly's team who writes about their proficiency.

Subscribe our blog

Get the latest post in your email.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.